In 2009, Zac Efron starred in 17 Again and showed off his sparkly blue eyes at the KCAs.

The Jonas Brothers looked stylish when they arrived at the '09 KCAs. Later, they just looked slimy.

Pop singer Jesse McCartney didn't have to battle anyone for attention at the '05 KCAs.

Dylan and Cole Sprouse star in The Suite Life on Deck, and they both looked super-sweet at the '09 KCAs.

American Idol made David Archuleta famous, but at the '09 KCAs, his smile made him look totally huggable.

Nathan Kress plays Freddie, the tech guy, on iCarly. He didn't need any gadgets to look good at the '09 KCAs.

Nat Wolff, the Naked Brothers Band's lead singer, performs on stage at the '08 KCAs

In 2009, Nolan Gerard Funk walked the orange carpet at the KCAs and rocked as Nikko in Spectacular!

Remember Avan Jogia from the '09 KCAs? He plays Beck in the new Nick show Victorious.

Red suspenders are always cute, but they're even cuter on Simon Curtis from Spectacular!

Josh Hutcherson starred in Cirque du Freak: The Vampire's Assistant, and looked freakishly cute at the '09 KCAs.

In 2009, Corbin Bleu starred in Free Style and looked oh-so-charming at the KCAs.

Chase Crawford stars in Gossip Girl, and he looked cute enough to gossip about backstage at the '09 KCAs.

Tyler James Williams from Everybody Hates Chris is just plain lovable at the '09 KCAs.

Drake Bell is funny on Drake and Josh, but he looked seriously cute at the '06 KCAs.

Josh Peck from Drake and Josh saved his biggest, cutest smile for the '09 KCAs.

Pete Wentz from Fall Out Boy is half casual, half formal, and ALL cute at the '09 KCAs.

Which Jonas brother looked the cutest at the '08 KCAs? It's too close to call.